iHub Research By Nanjira Sambuli / October 3, 2013
How Useful Is A Tweet?: A review of the first tweets from the Westgate Attack
As of March 2013, Twitter had approximately 550 million active users worldwide, with about 200 million monthly active users, and an average of 400 million tweets sent everyday globally.
Research analyzing the characteristics of information sharing on Twitter has found that people share information differently on the site as compared to other social networking sites, enabling it to possibly be used as a news media in addition to a social network. Since Twitter’s launch in 2006, it has been a source of real-time updates on various events. Highlights of its unique usage include during the Boston Marathon bombings, when first updates were found on the social networking tool. Another example is during the Turkish protests (May/June 2013) where Twitter was used to spread information about the demonstrations on the ground, and where, unlike other recent uprisings, around 90% of all geolocated tweets came from within Turkey (and 50% from within Istanbul). At least 2 million tweets mentioning hashtags relating to the Turkish protests had been generated within the first 18 hours.
Literature supporting the idea that Twitter breaks news/reports news faster than traditional newswire providers has been growing. At iHub Research, we also found this to be the case during the 2013 Kenya General Elections, where for instance, Twitter broke news of a violent incident in Kisumu, after the Supreme Court Ruling. Two weeks ago, we again found this to be the case with the attack on Nairobi’s Westgate mall (September 21st, 2013).
To better understand how the conversation on Twitter began, we manually searched through a Twitter archive, and derived a timeline with a minute-by-minute reconstruction of how information about the attack was initially shared and propagated. We used keywords of the general area and the mall itself, i.e. by searching for tweets with the words ‘Westlands’ and ‘Westgate.’
Who Tweeted What, and When:
We have found that the first tweet referring to the incident was generated at 12:38PM (GMT+3).
The first (local) media house to tweet about the incident was K24 TV at 1.11PM , 33 minutes and 17 seconds after the first tweet, advising people to steer clear of the mall, based on a lead shared by one of their journalists.
Citizen TV followed one minute later (1.12PM) informing that they would be sharing updates on the reported shootout at the mall. AP was the first international media to break the story at 1.15PM.
The first government authority to tweet was The National Disaster Operations Centre, (NDOC Kenya) at 1:05PM, mentioning reports from #KoT (Kenyans on Twitter) and that the police were informed, with the area police responding.
Some Initial Numbers:
Between 12PM and 1PM (GMT+3) (original Tweets only):
Between 12PM- 1PM (GMT+3): (original tweets, retweets and replies)
Between 12 and 2PM (GMT+3): (original Tweets only)
Between 12PM and 2PM (GMT+3) (original Tweets, retweets and replies)
The First 12 Minutes of the Siege, As Tweeted
Analyzing the characteristics of the first tweets, we found that most were posed in question format asking if anyone else had information or if others had heard the gunshots and explosions. We also found first-hand accounts from those inside the mall, and others confirming the venue of the incident. Below is a description of tweeting activity during the first 12 minutes, and more tweets covering that timeline are storified here.
- The first tweet referenced the Westlands area, indicating that though not an eyewitness account, the sound of gunshots could be heard in the general vicinity. This is also the case with some of the initial tweets generated by others who were at the Sarit Centre, a mall approximately 850 metres.
- The first tweet referencing Westgate (approximately one minute after first tweet) also poses a question on what was happening, ‘loads of loud sounds’ having been heard by the tweeter.
- 27 seconds later, another tweet indicates gunshots at Westgate.
- A tweet (1 minute, 2 seconds after) from someone at the mall informs that there have been gunshots ongoing for about 5 minutes, by their approximation.
- The first geo-tagged tweet is generated. The tweeter later indicates that the ‘gunshot-like sounds’ were so loud they could hear them from the Sarit Centre, the venue to which her tweet is referenced. (Lower Kabete Road).
- The first tweet referencing an explosion is structured in a format indicating that the tweeter was confirming it.
- A journalist with the Standard Media Group who was around Westgate informs of heavily armed thugs having taken over the mall.
- First tweeter sends a follow up tweet asking if anyone else in Westlands had heard the gunshots.
- Another journalists alludes to small arms fire and explosions coming from either Westlands, or Gigiri, an area a few kilometres past Westgate.
- First reference to grenades being used at Westgate.
- First tweet to major local media houses, inquiring if they have any news on the incident.
- Tweet from another journalist/foreign correspondent who talks of several explosions followed by 10 minutes of running gunfight in Westlands.
- A tweeter informs that he’s confirmed with ‘his guy on the ground’ that something is going on around Westgate.
- First tweet asking people to keep away from Westgate.
- A tweeter inside Westgate tags the Kenya Red Cross, asking to get them (those inside the mall) help.
- First tweet asking for someone to call the police.
- Second tweet to the Kenya Red Cross.
- A tweet from someone who’s heard a ‘bunch of explosions’.
- Tweet from someone inside Nakumatt Westgate requesting that people alert cops.
- Another tweet from someone inside Westgate who informs on two grenades (exploding) and hundreds of gunshots fired (still ongoing 10 minutes later). Also informs that ‘they’ are hiding but safe.
- First image on the Westgate situation is tweeted.
- Another tweet offering situational awareness is sent, and media tagged.
- A journalist with K24 sends a warning tweet advising people to steer clear of the mall, as there’s a shootout taking place.
- A retweet tagging the Inspector General and asking one of the first tweeters within the mall if they are ok (The Inspector General responds directly informing that police are at the scene approximately 32 minutes later).
- Another tweet asking #KoT what’s happening is cc’d to Westgate’s security management company (Securex East Africa responds approximately 5 minutes later and informs that their team is on the ground).
We are still analyzing the tweeting activity that continued over the unfolding of the 4/5 day siege, as the world took to Twitter for updates. We will follow up with more information in days to come. This Westgate example gives further support for the findings derived from our 3Vs Crowdsourcing Framework Research, which will be officially launched at our cocktail event this evening, October 3, 2013.
Related post: Forensics Analysis of #Westgate Tweets
Patrick Meier at 14:54:01PM Thursday, October 3, 2013
Many thanks for sharing and for posting to my blog post. Just realized that we didn’t include Westlands in our initial Twitter analysis, so will be sure to correct that in subsequent analysis.
Nanjira Sambuli at 15:00:47PM Thursday, October 3, 2013
Cool. We look forward to your subsequent analysis and do let us know how we can contribute given that we are looking at the same kind of content. If you can, do join us on Google Hangout for our cocktail event tonight where we will discuss some of these issues. We will be tweeting out the link shortly.Reply
Victoria Luckie at 15:51:24PM Thursday, October 3, 2013
Was tweeting and RT other’s tweets since day one (was not personally in Kenya at the time but have lived there and am a journalist) did not include Westgate hashtag and account is protected but if you want to take a look I tweet as Alex Cabrini and if you request it I will add you. It may be worth including fb too. I first head via a friend in Westlands via FB.Reply
marysherlie at 15:56:39PM Thursday, October 3, 2013
Thanks for this analysis.Its also a key note on how strong social media has been.I would like to know what was the first place one saw the news on westgate and where do most people go to when they want to write something happening.Reply
Forensics Analysis of #Westgate Tweets (Updated) | iRevolution at 18:05:11PM Thursday, October 3, 2013
[…] we have just fixed the oversight. This explains why the original results below differ from the iHub’s analysis and vice […]Reply
Anthony at 12:00:55PM Friday, October 4, 2013
You’ve probably seen this, but just in case, a similar project on JKIA fire social media coverage http://www.slideshare.net/shanxz/jkiaReply
Kelvin Nyongesa Muchuma at 16:08:28PM Friday, October 4, 2013
woo! am loving you guyz. a member for life count me.Reply
Angela Crandall at 13:25:44PM Monday, October 7, 2013
Thanks Anthony. Cool share.Reply
kevin at 17:26:49PM Monday, October 7, 2013
these guys used topsy proReply
Nanjira Sambuli at 22:53:13PM Monday, October 7, 2013
Cool share indeed. Thanks!Reply
Umati Phase II : Findings from July- September 2013 Monitoring Period at 17:22:58PM Friday, November 22, 2013
[…] the topics discussed online. This was evident in the online conversations around the ICC cases and Nairobi Westgate Mall attack, around which a surge in hate speech was noted. In another analysis of the two major news topics in […]Reply
#UmatiForum: The Many Faces of Online Hate Speech in Kenya at 11:49:30AM Tuesday, January 21, 2014
[…] to be observed even after the election period. Most notably, events such as the ICC cases and the Nairobi Westgate Mall attack have been observed to trigger the propagation of hateful speech, and further, a subset of it termed […]Reply
iHub Research’s 2014 Tech Outlook: Predictions, Convictions…and Questions at 11:50:40AM Saturday, February 15, 2014
[…] journalists. We also continue to see opinions, convictions and thoughts on various matters shared. Social media was also instrumental during the Nairobi Westgate Mall Attack as a source of information, misinformation and disinformation alike, but it was the primary pulse […]Reply
- iHub Cluster
- iHub Consulting
- iHub Research
- iHub Robotics
- iHub UXlab
- PIVOT East partners with Tech hubs for 2014 startups competition
- Screening of Girl Rising – empowering young women in ICT and entrepreneurship
- Why calling yourself a Startup could be Killing your Business
- INTEL IDEATION CAMP
- A Recap of #UmatiForum: The Many Faces of Online Hate Speech in Kenya